International Marketing Communication - Cultural influence
Researcher
Geert Hofstede defined culture as "the collective mind which distinguishes
the members of a human group from another "(Hofstede, 1991, p.5). Culture,
in this sense, includes the systems of values; and the values are among essential
components of a culture (Adler, 1997, p 15).
Therefore,
the culture is a collective phenomenon that is shaped by the social environment
of the individuals and not by the individuals themselves. Essentially, culture
is the whole legacy of a society, transmitted by word speech, literature or
other forms of communication, but also the way of life and thought of that society
that are passed on from generation to generation. Culture reflects the human
side of economic environment.
Culture has
a strong impact on marketing activity. Marketing involves gaining profit by
meeting needs, human desires and requirements. In order to better meet them, the
target-market culture must be understood.
Cultural influence on product decisions
There is a
wide range of decisions regarding the product, the product itself, branding,
packaging, labelling, warranties and after-sales service, positioning.
Regarding the product itself, the important characteristics that are influenced
by the culture are the dimensions of the product, shape of the product, the
content itself of the product, the quality, methods of use of the product, the
product color. Product dimensions as size, capacity or volume are subject to market
and environmental influences, and often require separate solutions for each
market. One of the important factors is the choice of the system metric or
nemetric. The company must go beyond the simple conversion from one system to
another. And also other environment factors influence the size of the product.
Japanese hands are smaller; Americans feet are bigger, so gloves and shoe
manufacturers have to take into account this fact. Also, houses in some
countries are less spacious and manufacturers of houses items should take this
into account. Even in the countries where the customers’ preferences seem to be
similar, there are significant differences regarding the size and capacity of
the products. The European Union consumers have special preferences on washing
machines. Italians prefer washing machines with a capacity of 4 kg, English a capacity
of 5 kg and Germans and Swedes prefer washing machines with a capacity of 6 kg.
The product shape is an important element
in the decision to produce. In this respect, the symbolism is a key-factor in
the decision to produce (Dubois, 1987). The symbolic representations have theirs
expression in tradition and habits. If the symbolic attribute of a product is
negatively charged, it will be amended. The Middle East, the round or square representations
are accepted. The six-pointed star or the raised forefinger are avoided.
The content of the product itself is also
influenced by the culture, in particular the consumer goods. The Muslims do not
eat pork and do not drink alcohol. Therefore, in the Islamic countries the animal
fat should be replaced by the vegetal fat due to the religious restrictions. The
Brahman Hindus do not eat meat at all. For example, the Australian company, Uncle
Ben's, a producer of food for pets had to eliminate pork even from the food for
the animals, as the consumption of Pork is forbidden by the Islam religion. If
there are a large number of illiterates or women are excluded from education, the
products should be simplified.
A product
may have varied uses on other markets, and the methods of preparation may be
different. For example, the American company Dunkin's Donuts, didn’t success at
the beginning in Brazil, because usually the locals do not serve breakfast. So
they had to adapt to the local market, making products from local fruits for
dessert or parties.
Neither the
company Campbell wasn’t successful in Brazil with his beef and vegetable soups,
as the Brazilian housewives prefer dry soups like Knorr and they add local
ingredients.
An
important role has the colors of the product.
They can be used to distinguish the mark - the company Herz, for example, uses
yellow and Avis green. Rolls Royce uses shiny silver to create the image of a luxury
car. Pepsi-Cola had many problems when they changed the color of their machines
from dark blue in blue sky in the countries from South-East Asia, as this color
symbolizes there mourning and death.
The brand is influenced by the following elements of
culture: language , aesthetics and cultural values. The brand name may be
influenced primarily by the language if it is not translated correctly and its
meaning has a negative connotation . For example, the expression "no va
" in Spanish means "no go " and can be confused with the Italian
word " nova " which means "new". As a result, the company
General Motors was not successful in the Spanish-speaking countries with its
Nova model . Also, the word " Fresca " (name of U.S. soft drink
Fresca ) is a Spanish slang for lesbians; and the cars brand Pinto from Ford
had to be changed into Corcel in Brazil , after it was discovered that in this
country " pinto " is a slang for the male sexual organ. Sometimes the
same word has a completely different meaning in other countries (false
friends). For example, the word "diet" in French suggests a poor
health. So, in France, Coca –Cola doesn’t use " Diet Coca -Cola ",
but" Coca- Cola Light ".
In the countries
with high patriotism, the local brands must be used in order to access the market.
For example, in 1996, the Vietnamese government has imposed that the name of all
the brands to be local. (Kotabe, Helsen, 1998, p 336).
The decisions
regarding packaging focus essentially on the shape and on the package structure,
its size, color, material culture. The Americans prefer to buy mayonnaise and
mustard in jars, while in Germany and Switzerland are preferred the tubes.
Also, in the United States usually the beer is packaged in cans, while in Europe
is packed in bottles. The size of the package varies depending on the purchase model
and the market conditions. In low-income countries, the goods are usually sold by
piece and not in packages with more products.
The labeling involves the use of the
appropriate language. If the label contains important information for the
consumer, usually it must be written in their own language, which implies the
existence of labels for each market. Moreover, the symbols on the labels and
packages have their explanation in the traditions and customs. In India, for
example, elephants, parrots, tigers are used as trade marks on labels and
packages. In countries where the percentage of illiterates is high, the labels
should be adapted accordingly.
The influence of culture on promotion decisions
The element
of the promotional mix the most influenced by the culture is the advertising.
The following
aspects of advertising are influenced by culture : media , contents, advertising
budget and the relationship advertising
agency-client. Perhaps the most dominant feature of the global advertising is
the proliferation of advertising media. Media advertising can be influenced by
the material culture which limits the available supports. In developed
countries you can find the full range of media: television, radio, newspapers,
cinema and billboards. In the countries
which are developing, some of these media - television, newspapers - are
missing, especially in rural areas. Even in the countries where these media exist,
there are restrictions which limit their availability for advertisement. These
restrictions range from a total ban on television advertising (Sweden) to limit
it to 15 to 20 minutes a day in lumps of 3 to 5 minutes. Some countries don’t
have enough magazines and newspapers to insert all advertisements required and
others didn’t introduce yet the satellite television or cable. Even when there is
media, it may not be available for advertising. For example, in Norway,
Denmark, Sweden, Finland, Switzerland and Saudi Arabia you cannot make radio
advertising. In Norway, Denmark, Sweden and Saudi Arabia neither the commercial
television is not available for advertising ( Jeannet , Hennessey , 1998, p
476). Advertising content is influenced by material culture, language,
religion, education, customs and traditions and norms.
Conclusions
Because the
decisions regarding the marketing mix and the policies standardization/adaptation
are essential in the international marketing, further research is needed on the
impact of cultural variables. Before this, the cultural structures relevant in marketing
still need to be identified. This has been achieved so far by using the four cultural
dimensions of Hofstede for estimating the cultural differences. However, the
dimensions of Hofstede may not correspond to the objectives of international
marketing. The samples of Hofstede were selected by sex and age (Usunier, 2000,
p 74), not by socioeconomic class, geosocial regions, ethnic backgrounds, etc..
Therefore, further research are necessary regarding the identification of
specific models (or commons) of consumption.
References
Adler, N.A.
(1997). International Dimensions of Organizational Bahaviour, SW College
Publishing,
Cincinnati
Dubois, B.
(1987). Culture et marketing, în Recherche et Applications en Marketing, vol.
11-1, pp. 47-64
Hofstede, G.
(1991). Cultures and
organizations: Software of the mind, McGraw-Hill, London
Kotabe, M.,
Helsen, K. (1998). Global Marketing Management, John Wiley and Sons, New York
Jeannet,
P.R.; Hennessey, H.D. (1998). International Marketing Management, Houghton,
Miffin
Company,
Boston
Tylor, E.B.
(1871). Primitive Culture, John Murray, London
Usunier,
J.C. (2000). Marketing Across Culture, Prentice Hall, London
It is enjoyable to read articles concerning cultural differences which widen the individual mind to the level one might have never thought of. You categorized nicely the product related attributes to be noted while moving country to country with examples; I would have liked to read even more on concrete cases where cultural differences are wide and important to understand.
ReplyDeleteThe article highlights also the importance of studying the target country and culture in detail before entering to the market. Research is seen essential. One successful marketing campaign in country of origin does not mean it could be copied to another market without understanding the cultural behaviors and models. Maybe the worst mistake is not to respect the local cultural, religion and ethical values. Such an act could cause severe damage to the brand and the whole company and difficult to restore.
Even the well-known companies have made failures of entry as the article pointed out. It evokes questions what has gone wrong in the research, or is the research carried out at all trusting the already working concept? Or have they been ignorant altogether? Whatever the answer is it deepens the importance of the local research, where local agents or natives could be used to help to understand the nature of the culture and plan brand positioning, marketing communication mix and plan accordingly.
-Tommi
Comments & Feedback from Kannan Balaram:
ReplyDeleteThe author Ramona Stanca has written this article with very many good examples in International Marketing Communication with Cultural influence. He has explained negative factors and how cultural influences make loss to business. Some of examples are interesting such as Muslims do not eat pork and do not drink alcohol, Brahman Hindus do not eat meat at all, and Local Brazilians usually do not serve breakfast. Ramona has mentioned with examples, the importance of words selection in the promotion of brand marketing. Of course, the expression "no va " in Spanish means "no go " and can be confused with the Italian word " nova " which means "new". As a result, the General Motors was not successful in the Spanish-speaking countries with its Nova model. Even selection of colours also are being determined by cultural influence, likewise Pepsi-Cola had many problems when they changed the color of their machines from dark blue in blue sky in the countries from South-East Asia, as this color symbolizes there mourning and death. I too agree with author, In India, for example, elephants, parrots, tigers are used as trade marks on labels and packages. Even some culture group people like their local symbols are to be brand mark in their place. Government policies and standards are driven by their cultural influences. So, successes of these marketing communications also depend on the influence of cultural.
It would be nice that if the author could mention more positive side of cultural influences. In other word, how international business could encase profits from cultural influences with examples. As I think, author’s statement of ‘Japanese hands are smaller; Americans feet are bigger, so gloves and shoe manufacturers have to take into account this fact’ – may not come under cultural influence. Same way, author’s view about availabilities of advertisement facilities in countries, in some points I could not able to consider in cultural influence. Because, I feel that inadequate of advertisement infrastructure facilities could not be considered as countries cultural. Finally, the author mentioned no radio advertisement in Norway, Denmark, Sweden, Finland, Switzerland and Saudi Arabia with reference of Jeannet , Hennessey , 1998, p 476. This statement may be needed to check in the point of commercial radios, which are broadcasting with advertisement from Finland.
By the way, overall your article is good and nice and also wishes!!!
I have always been interested in cultural differences and their impact on decisionmaking and therefore this article was interesting to read. It is true that cultural differences have huge influence for product and promotion decisions; what works in one culture may not work in another, so one should really find out about the culture and understand the cultural differences beforehand. If not, this could lead to misunderstandings and bad image for the company, for example because the customers may easily think the company does not understand their culture, or worse care about it at all, if it has not taken the differences into consideration when entering the market and communicating to the customers.
ReplyDeleteThe text was easy to read and there were many good practical examples included.